The legacy of the Washington Commanders, formerly the Redskins, is defined by a series of quarterbacks who have shaped the identity of the franchise. From the foundational years to the modern era, the search for the best signal-caller has been a constant narrative. Evaluating these players requires looking beyond just statistics and considering the context of their eras, the strength of their supporting cast, and the tangible impact they had on wins and losses.
Foundational Era and the Lombardi Legacy
The roots of the franchise are anchored in the name it carried for decades. During this period, the team was searching for stability and a defining leader. The journey through the 1970s set the stage for what would become a franchise benchmark.
Joe Theismann: The Hall of Fame Core
Joe Theismann stands as the definitive answer to who the best Redskins quarterback was during the franchise's storied history. Playing from 1974 to 1985, Theismann combined toughness, intelligence, and arm talent to lead the team to its only Super Bowl victory. His partnership with wide receiver Art Monk and the powerful running game created a balanced attack that opponents feared. Theismann's leadership during the 1982 season, culminating in a Super Bowl XVII victory over the Miami Dolphins, cemented his status as a franchise icon and a future Hall of Famer.
The Post-Theismann Transition and Struggle
Following Theismann's tragic leg injury in 1985, the franchise entered a prolonged period of uncertainty. This era was marked by high expectations followed by devastating setbacks, as the team searched for a franchise quarterback to replace a legend.
Doug Williams: A Pioneering Achievement
Doug Williams provided a moment of unparalleled glory in 1988 when he became the first African American quarterback to start and win a Super Bowl. His performance in Super Bowl XXII, where he was named MVP, remains legendary. However, his tenure with the franchise was unfortunately brief, and the team struggled to build sustained success around him in the years that followed.
The Modern Search for Consistency
Entering the 21st century, the franchise oscillated between hope and disappointment. The evolution of the quarterback position and the league's increasing parity made the search for a consistent leader more challenging but no less critical.
Mark Brunell and the 2005 Campaign
Mark Brunell brought veteran leadership and stability to the team during the mid-2000s. His tenure included a remarkable 2005 season where he guided the team to a surprising 10-6 record and a playoff berth. Brunell's experience and game management were vital during this period, showcasing what a veteran quarterback could do for the franchise.
Recent Efforts and the RGIII Era
The most recent chapter involved high hopes with Robert Griffin III. RGIII entered the league with immense fanfare, winning Offensive Rookie of the Year in 2012. His dynamic running ability electrified the team and created a exciting, fast-paced offense. Although injuries curtailed his time in Washington, his impact on the franchise and the excitement he generated remain significant.
Evaluating the Legacy
Determining the best Redskins quarterback is ultimately a comparison of impact and success. While modern players have showcased incredible talent, the foundation of the franchise was built by Theismann. His combination of skill, leadership, and a championship defines the standard. Williams provided a historic moment for the sport, while players like Brunell and RGIII highlighted the potential for future glory.
Looking ahead, the franchise continues its quest for quarterback excellence. The history of the position is a tapestry woven with triumph, heartbreak, and unwavering hope. The search for the next great leader remains the central story for the team and its dedicated fanbase.
